Pellet Fan
Accessories & Essentials => Knives, Sharpeners, Cutting Boards & Mats => Topic started by: Greg1 on March 30, 2018, 07:47:08 AM
-
Does anyone have any recommendations for a good quality 10" or 12" slicing knife. My budget won't allow for the high end knifes. I understand you get what you pay for, but I am seeing if anyone has and recommendations for a solid knife in the $25-$30 dollar range. Guessing it's a long shot but thought it was worth a shot. Appreciate any and all responses.
-
I have been very pleased with my Victorinox Cutlery 12-Inch Slicing Knife, Black Fibrox Handle. Mostly use it on brisket and rib roasts. Has stayed very sharp only with simple honing. Check out Amazon the price is about $40.
-
I recently purchased this one on the big A...its sort of multipurpose but its sharp, slices well and only $14.
Dexter-Russell Basics P94804B 10" Scalloped Slicer/Bread Knife with Black Polypropylene Handle
-
I have been very pleased with my Victorinox Cutlery 12-Inch Slicing Knife, Black Fibrox Handle. Mostly use it on brisket and rib roasts. Has stayed very sharp only with simple honing. Check out Amazon the price is about $40.
+1
-
If you have access to the Restaurant Depot, you could find one there. I think they sell Dexter. I have a few Dexter knives and they work fine for me.
-
Good advice given above. The big box membership stores might have a limited selection.
-
Mercer Culinary M23011 Millennia 11" Granton Edge Slicer Knife
That’s what I use.
-
If you have access to the Restaurant Depot, you could find one there. I think they sell Dexter. I have a few Dexter knives and they work fine for me.
How does Dexter compare to Victorinix? I will be going to KnifeWorks in Tennessee in a few days to look for a knife for slicing. I have two of the Victorinix knifes with the granton edge.
-
If you have access to the Restaurant Depot, you could find one there. I think they sell Dexter. I have a few Dexter knives and they work fine for me.
How does Dexter or Mercer compare to Victorinix? I will be going to KnifeWorks in Tennessee in a few days to look for a knife for slicing. I have two of the Victorinix knifes with the granton edge.
-
Thanks for starting this thread Greg. I am also looking for a slicing knife. Right now I have been using a 8 inch all purpose type knife.
-
Mercer Culinary M23011 Millennia 11" Granton Edge Slicer Knife
That’s what I use.
I just ordered this for $15 to try. If I like it and it doesn’t last I’ll order the Victorinox then. I have been using an electric and been happy that’s why I tried the cheaper first.
-
I bought a guard for mine and never put it in the sink with other dishes, it will take a slice out of your finger. I use a steel on mine and it's as sharp as the day I got it.
-
If you have access to the Restaurant Depot, you could find one there. I think they sell Dexter. I have a few Dexter knives and they work fine for me.
How does Dexter or Mercer compare to Victorinix? I will be going to KnifeWorks in Tennessee in a few days to look for a knife for slicing. I have two of the Victorinix knifes with the granton edge.
I have several Dexter knives and several Victorinox knives. IMO they hold their edge about the same, and have been happy with both. Dexter are a little more cost effective, Restaurant Depot has pretty good prices and selection on them.
-
I ordered and received the Mercer Culinary M23011 slicing Knife. I have only used it to slice and cube 8lbs of brisket point into burnt ends, but was very happy with how it performed.
-
Glad you are happy with what you bought. I am not big on spending big bucks on knives like I do on most other things. I just keep buying $20 or so one's until I find what works for my needs.
-
i just got a Mercer M23720 slicer and used on a brisket this past weekend - only used on the brisket so far, but seemed to work very well
-
To me knives are personal cook tools and no one size fits all. I say you go to a number of stores that sell knives and feel them to how they feel in the palm of your hand, the weight of them and of course the quality of build.
also know matter how expensive the knife if you do not keep a good edge on them they will fail you, so if you do not have a good knife sharpener I would recommend you also look into buying one. At least for me I found the chef knife to be my go to knife along with my pairing knives. :cool:
-
I have two Kirby knives an 8" and 10", and I can tell you that I use the 8" - 10 times more often. since it handles much easier and has the vertical eyelet reliefs that keep everything I slice from sticking to the side of the knife. Kirby knifes are at some restaurant supplies for around $40 bucks and both of these knives are at least 10 years old and only need to use the simple drawn carbide to keep them dangerously sharp.
-
I have been a cheap screw when it comes to knives. A few weeks ago, I helped my brother do some prep work for a catering job and had to cut about 100# of red potatoes. I used a Mercer Genesis 10" chef knife he had. It was so sharp, balanced, light, and had a great grip. It is not top of the line, but it was better than anything I ever used. Unfortunately, its been on backorder at the Restaurant Store where he bought his. I found a 9" on Amazon for about $35 so I ordered it instead of the $55 10". Will see how I like it.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001B1AG7Y/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
-
According to the Amazon listing, that knife is x50 Cr Mo V15 steel. That’s pretty good knife steel, used in many German knives. It’s not particularly hard, ≈56 HRC (Rockwell). That means it’s easy to grind and it’s not likely to chip because it’s not brittle. But it sacrifices a bit in edge-holding ability so in hard use it will need to be frequently corrected with a butcher’s steel and the bevel will sometimes require “tuning up” with a grindstone. See Hammer Stahl 14-inch Slicing Knife (https://pelletfan.com/index.php?topic=4844.msg56313#msg56313) for a more in-depth discussion of X50CrMoV15 stainless steel’s properties.
The 15% chromium gives it excellent corrosion resistance so it will continue to look clean and shiny for as long as the blade lasts through years of regrinding. Also, it appears to be the generally preferred forged blade.
I think it’s a good choice and a good buy.
-
Looks like a good Chefs knife!
-
I have been a cheap screw when it comes to knives. A few weeks ago, I helped my brother do some prep work for a catering job and had to cut about 100# of red potatoes. I used a Mercer Genesis 10" chef knife he had. It was so sharp, balanced, light, and had a great grip. It is not top of the line, but it was better than anything I ever used. Unfortunately, its been on backorder at the Restaurant Store where he bought his. I found a 9" on Amazon for about $35 so I ordered it instead of the $55 10". Will see how I like it.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001B1AG7Y/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
A little late, but you could have ordered the 10" from Amazon.
On that page for the 9" knife is a "size" button, and you could select the 10" Chef Knife there.
It's $58.64 though.
I guess the 9" is a better bargain, but at the expense of being a little smaller.
-
Yeah, I consciously went cheap. If I don't like the 9" versions, I will return it and buy the 10" version.
-
My :2cents:
- Get an edge guard and use it. Or store it either in a block or on a magnetic holder. Sharp knives need respect and protection.... Lee Valley has excellent inexpensive blade guards.
- Using a steel to realign the blade either before or after use helps maintain the edge. A touch-up during a long cutting session may also help.
- Once it eventually dulls, it should be properly sharpened.
-
I rarely use a chefs knife. I have 2 of the Misen knives when they first came on Kickstarter. I have used one of them a couple times. I usually end up using the Henkels International (China Made) santuko in place of chefs knife. I did add a 6" chef knife to my cart for the next order. I seem to like the shorter knives for most of what I do. I have been using a Mercer 6" boning knife for a few years, I like the feel of it in my hand better than the popular Victorinox one I have.
Those Mercer blade guards are nice also I have them on several of my knives.
Any one use a Ceramic knives? I bought a cheap set and I like them for some things.
-
There is a post by bobitis on the ceramic knives. Wonder whatever happened to that guy?
As for the Mercer, I had a knife in my hand that felt more comfortable than that 10" chef's knife.
-
CERAMIC KNIFE - Well: I had one. It cut well, nothing spectacular. It was the rage @ the time a few years back..
The downside: -A) extremely brittle, easily chipped or broken. Not for chopping or prying. B) Can't sharpen, that is with anything homeowner.