Pellet Fan

All Things Considered => General Discussion--Food Related => Topic started by: Canadian John on October 03, 2019, 09:03:14 AM

Title: Cooking Fuel Ratings
Post by: Canadian John on October 03, 2019, 09:03:14 AM

 This is how I perceive the effect different heat sources have on the taste of food. Texture can also be influenced to a degree.

 From the top down. The top being the best.

                                                                WOOD

                                                                LUMP CHARCOAL*

                                                                CHARCOAL BRIQUETS*

                                                                GAS either NG or PROPANE*

                                                                ELECTRICITY*

  * May be enhanced using wood: chunks or chips... Used outdoors exclusively.

  When cooking inside, I find that a gas oven wins over electric. Gas has less tendency to dry things out.

  Does this align with your experiences?
Title: Re: Cooking Fuel Ratings
Post by: MikeMcQ on October 03, 2019, 02:28:02 PM
I believe some bakers prefer electric for bread for a crisper crust.
Title: Re: Cooking Fuel Ratings
Post by: Bentley on October 03, 2019, 08:28:24 PM
It has been so long since I cooked outdoors with anything but wood I can't make an objective observation.  We have been electric oven for last 5 years...I dont know that I remember much difference between gas and electric.  Although I would prefer to broil on gas stove!
Title: Re: Cooking Fuel Ratings
Post by: MikeMcQ on October 03, 2019, 08:49:53 PM
We have been electric oven for last 5 years...I dont know that I remember much difference between gas and electric.  Although I would prefer to broil on gas stove!
We've had our little 4 burner all gas Viking ~15 years. Never had an issue baking gas oven but don't bake bread hardly ever. Broiler wise don't use it often, but when I do gotta pay attention cause that puppy if FIERCE!
Title: Re: Cooking Fuel Ratings
Post by: cookingjnj on October 06, 2019, 11:40:39 AM
I agree with your ratings CJ.  Nothing beats wood, and charcoal either lump or briquets comes closer.  Gas really just impacts flavor with the searing of what is being cooked.
Title: Re: Cooking Fuel Ratings
Post by: ZCZ on October 07, 2019, 01:47:44 PM
We have been electric oven for last 5 years...I dont know that I remember much difference between gas and electric.  Although I would prefer to broil on gas stove!
We've had our little 4 burner all gas Viking ~15 years. Never had an issue baking gas oven but don't bake bread hardly ever. Broiler wise don't use it often, but when I do gotta pay attention cause that puppy if FIERCE!

Back in 1998 I spent a week at Viking Range in Greenwood, MS.  Quite the place.  It was October so temps weren’t too bad. I was there to train them on their new robotic press brake. At the time their “low end” outdoor gas grill started at $1,500. All stainless of course. Which is the route Memphis grills ended up going, as you well know. Two high quality units.
Z