Pellet Fan

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to Pellet Fan!

Poll

What is acceptable for Temperature Fluctuation?

Less than 5 degrees plus/minus
- 1 (3.6%)
5-10 degrees plus/minus
- 5 (17.9%)
10-20 degrees plus/minus
- 12 (42.9%)
20-30 degrees plus/minus
- 10 (35.7%)

Total Members Voted: 24


Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: How tight of Temp Control is needed and how does that impact Smoke Flavor?  (Read 875 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Rick

  • Using less gas.
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 39

I'm just curious.  I've been thinking about this for awhile.  I'm removing any brand names.  I can't recall if that was appropriate or not.

I hear a lot about temperature control with pellet cookers and how some brands didn't have tight enough control.  I'm wondering what you consider acceptable.

I could be WAY off on my theory, but here it is:

I think Pellet cookers that have very tight variances in temperature swing produce less smoke.  I'm wondering if they produce less smoke flavor.  On the other hand, I've seen some popular (and some expensive) brands that seem to do a better job of putting smoke flavor onto the meat.  I also hear some folks say that these same brands seem to have greater temp swings.

I remember seeing a certain high end pellet cooker at the Royal in 2015 (with PH.com).   It seemed to put out a lot more smoke than other pellet cookers. 

On the other hand, my pellet cooker did not have any temp swings.  It was usually within 5 degrees of the setting.  I didn't think it put much smoke flavor out.  And it certainly didn't have smoke coming out of the stack, outside of start up.

Is it possible (and this is my theory), that temp swings create more smoke flavor in the world of pellet cookers?  The firing and smoldering of pellets in the pot produce more smoke than a constant, clean burn?

I know smoke flavor is subjective.  Some folks love it.  Others hate heavy smoke.  I consider myself some where in the middle and leaning to the LIGHT Smoke flavor. 

Your thoughts? I would love to hear from those that have used multiple brands of pellet cookers.
« Last Edit: October 17, 2017, 03:13:29 PM by Rick »
Logged

hughver

  • Friends Want you to cook way to much.
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2195
  • University of Louisiana

IMO, temperature swings are inevitable in pellet grills (or any cooking device). The tolerable amount is probably a function of percent of set temperature and product being cooked rather than a fixed variation, i.e., a 20* variation at a set temp. of 500* is most likely acceptable but 20* at 150* not so much.  :2cents:
Logged
--Hugh -- Sun Lakes, AZ. Traeger Select W/SS4, BGE-L, Charbroil Inferred Gas, Smokey Mountain Vertical Gas

Clonesmoker

  • Digging the Pellet Smoke.
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 348

Seems that I get more swings the higher temp I go. This is from left to right. Below 200 it is pretty stable across. I go to 300, I get around 20 degree difference from left to right with the right side hotter.
Logged

LowSlowJoe

  • Thinkin about Renouncing Charcoal.
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 735
  • Smoking out of southeastern Michigan

Let's not confuse temperature swings and temperature variations.

Temperature swings should refer to temperature that swings above and below a average temperature that is measured somewhere inside the grill.

Temperature variation is what I think of as the variation of temperature as measured at different points around the inside of the grill.  Side to side variations for example... or front to back... or right rear to left front.

These are totally different things. 
Logged
Fast Eddy PG500, Traeger Texas, Traeger Junior, Traeger PTG, GMG Davy Crockett

Bobitis

  • Thinkin about Renouncing Charcoal.
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 855
  • Contrary to popular belief, bacon is a vegetable

My Jr will swing 50-60 degrees and it cooks just fine. When I 1st got it, it would do 120+. THAT was a problem.
Logged
How can you have any pudding if you don't eat yer meat?

Rick

  • Using less gas.
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 39

I do like the Yoders for that reason.  It's on my short list.  How is it for Grilling (using grill grates)?
Logged

Bobitis

  • Thinkin about Renouncing Charcoal.
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 855
  • Contrary to popular belief, bacon is a vegetable

IMHO...

I think folks put too much emphasis on visual smoke.

I have an 18" Weber WSM that will lay on more smoke than most would like. Running properly, you can barely see any smoke at all. Just a simple wisp of blue smoke once in a while. It was a pain to babysit that thing when it was running and I finally got tired of it.

My JR puts out copious amounts of blue smoke up to about 275 deg. It doesn't come anywhere close to the smoke flavor laid on by the WSM.

I've no idea why... The only thing I can imagine is the use of chunk wood vs sawdust wood. Again with the why...
Logged
How can you have any pudding if you don't eat yer meat?

dshaffes

  • Using less gas.
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 26

I have some of the same questions as Rick.  My Traeger with the Pro Controller holds temp very well (+/- 15) and pumps out sweet blue smoke as it go through its cycles.  I have an opportunity to upgrade to a Smoke Daddy PID, but think it might produce less smoke flavor.  What does everyone think?
Logged

Canadian John

  • Friends Want you to cook way to much.
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2698
  • HAPPY COOKING, Canadian John

 dshaffes; I would stay w/ the "stock" controller for more smoke for sure..The temp swings you are encountering are darn good. As you should know by now from the results of several cooks,the Pro the controller did a good job.  A PID will be able to tighten swings at the cost of less smoke...If you are a numbers man go w/ the PID.  Just my thinking.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up