I am the KFC of amateur guitar players. I decided that I did not have the talent to do everything, so I chose one style to do right.
I am a traditional blues guitar player. My preference is the delta style of folks such as Charley Patton, Robert Johnson, Son House and Willie Brown.
I am all finger style, particularly the unique brand of finger style used by the old blues players. I also play a lot of slide guitar since it is important to the style.
I too, have a pile of guitars stashed about, including a couple of resonators (metal body Dobro, and wood body square neck). I even have some electrics guitars including a lap steel and a bass.
I really don't understand much about making electrics do what they are capable of, not that I would want to try if I had the time.
It is all fun and great relaxation. I learned many years back that if guitars are to be played, they have to be out. As such, I have a couple of multiguitar racks around my house so I can just pick one up at any time and play.
Oh, and when I use a flat pick I feel like I am trying to rip the strings in half. I never developed the touch for flat picking. Like I said, KFC. If I make the menu too large, I won't be able to do anything well.